An alternative to Bulldog skincare: how to choose your next one

For a great many men, Bulldog was the first skincare they ever bought on purpose. It sits at eye level, it is priced so that trying it costs very little, and nothing on the packaging asks you to have an opinion about skincare. That is a genuine achievement and it is why, for a lot of people, the habit starts there.

It is also why men eventually type "Bulldog skincare alternative" into a search box. Once the habit exists, the question changes. It stops being whether to bother and becomes what to use, which is a harder question and a much more interesting one.

What follows is an honest read of what Bulldog is good at, who it suits, and what a man might reasonably want instead. We make a competing range, so treat this as a view with a stake in it, and judge the reasoning rather than the source.

What Bulldog is good at

Bulldog describes itself as "purpose built for men" and works from natural origin ingredients combined with "carefully selected man-made ingredients to offer superb performance at an affordable price" ¹. That sentence is worth reading twice, because it is an unusually candid statement of what the brand is for. It is not chasing the most concentrated actives available. It is chasing a good product that most men can afford without thinking about it.

The range is organised by skin type. Original for normal skin, plus lines for sensitive skin, oil-prone skin and mature skin, an energising line for tired-looking skin, and an Advanced range the brand describes as "formulated using potent natural origin and carefully selected active ingredients" ²³. Beyond the face there is body, hair, beard and shave, so one brand can cover an entire bathroom shelf. Products are cruelty-free and vegan certified ¹.

Who that suits is easy to describe. A man who wants to be looked after without becoming a hobbyist, who would rather buy one brand for everything, and who wants the cost of a mistake to be low. If that is you, there is no argument here worth having. Stay where you are.

Why men start looking anyway

In our experience the reasons are consistent, and none of them is really a complaint about any particular brand.

The first is that the routine outgrows the shelf. Three or four steps get tiring, and at some point you would rather have fewer products doing more each, applied in under two minutes, than a cupboard you have to manage.

The second is that a specific thing has started to bother you. Shine that arrives by three in the afternoon. Dark circles that make people ask whether you slept. General skincare is aimed at everyone, which means it is not aimed at that.

The third is proof. Most men's skincare, at every price point, is sold on description rather than on a measurement. Once you notice how rarely a number arrives with a panel size attached, it is difficult to stop noticing.

The fourth is fragrance, and it is worth taking seriously if your skin reacts to things. Fragrance allergy is second only to nickel as a cause of allergic contact dermatitis and affects roughly one adult in a hundred ⁴. That is a label to check on any product from any brand, ours included.

The useful question is never which brand is best. It is which set of trade-offs you are happy to live with, because every formula in this category is a set of trade-offs.

What actually separates one men's brand from another

Four things, and price is not one of them.

Where the actives come from. Two products can list the same plant and behave completely differently, because a species is not a specification. How the material was grown, how it was processed and how it was stabilised decide what reaches your face.

Whether it was tested on men. Men's skin is measurably different. In vivo work on 300 people found men with higher sebum production and different surface pH and hydration profiles from women ⁵, and sebum output is the single largest driver of how a moisturiser behaves on your face by lunchtime ⁶.

Whether it accounts for skin tone. Almost nothing in men's skincare does, and around the eye it matters most, because the causes of dark circles differ by tone ⁷.

Whether the finish suits you at four in the afternoon. Not at the moment you apply it. Hours later, in a lift, under office lighting.

Where we sit

YCODE is built on microalgae. The Chlorella vulgaris in our formulas is grown in closed photobioreactors in Iceland and Barcelona rather than harvested from the sea, so it cannot carry heavy metals, pesticides or microplastics from open water, and it is cold-pressed and stabilised immediately. That is the whole reason we chose it, and the long version is here. Every formula we make is fragrance-free.

The Hydrating Face Serum is the first step after washing, with niacinamide second on the ingredient list, hyaluronic acid and Chlorella. Niacinamide is one of the few actives with measured effects on sebum output at concentrations men actually get in a serum ⁸.

YCODE Hydrating Face Serum, independent consumer trial ADSL 2025-0056, 50 men, four weeks.

The Mattifying Moisturiser goes over it. It is a moisturiser first: deep hydration that holds all day, formulated for every skin type, with oil balanced and the look of pores refined. In its own trial, 87% said their skin appeared rehydrated and 81% that it absorbed with no greasy film, on 53 men over four weeks.

The Advanced Eye Serum comes in three formulas matched to skin tone. Its figures come from published ingredient studies conducted by Eurofins Dermscan on 111 volunteers of mean age 42, measured at 15 minutes and 15 days, not from a consumer trial of the finished product: 90% dark circles visibly reduced, 89% under-eye bags reduced, 86% fine lines and wrinkles smoothed.

How to switch without wasting money

Change one thing at a time. Replacing an entire routine at once tells you nothing, because if your skin improves or reacts you will not know which product did it.

Give each change a fortnight. Skin turns over on a slower clock than your patience does.

Judge it in daylight, on your own face, at the end of a working day. That is the only test that counts, and it is free.

If you want a shortcut, our two-minute skin analysis will point you at one product rather than a routine. And if you are weighing several brands at once, we have written the same sort of piece on alternatives to Cardon, alternatives to Lumin and alternatives to Lab Series, Every Man Jack and Horace.

Written by

Freddie Sheridan

I started YCODE because most skincare was never designed for men’s skin. What I write here is what the formulators taught me, and what the trials actually found.

More about YCODE →